Peer Review

Peer Review Process

Hastagina: Jurnal Kriya dan Industri Kreatif is dedicated to ensuring the quality and integrity of scholarly content. All submitted manuscripts undergo a rigorous review process based on the Double-Blind Review model.

01

Double-Blind Review Model

This model ensures objectivity and minimizes potential bias by maintaining complete anonymity throughout the review cycle:

  • • Reviewers' Anonymity: Reviewers are unaware of the authors' identity, institution, or background.
  • • Authors' Anonymity: Authors are unaware of the reviewers' names or identities.
02

Duration & Ethical Commitment

Review Duration: The entire peer-review process typically takes 4 to 8 weeks, depending on manuscript complexity and reviewer responsiveness.

Ethical Commitment: All editors, reviewers, and authors must uphold COPE publication ethics, respecting confidentiality and process integrity throughout.
03

Stages of the Review Process

Step Responsible Party Description
I. Initial Screening Editor-in-Chief / Editorial Team Assessed for journal scope compliance, author guidelines adherence, and plagiarism screening (max 20% similarity). Failed manuscripts are desk-rejected.
II. Assignment of Reviewers Editor-in-Chief / Section Editor Manuscript is anonymized and sent to at least two independent expert reviewers knowledgeable in the field.
III. Peer Review (Double-Blind) Reviewers Evaluates originality, methodological soundness, creative process, clarity, and theoretical contribution. Detailed feedback is submitted to editors.
IV. Editorial Decision Editor-in-Chief / Section Editor Decision is made: Accept Submission, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, or Reject Submission.
V. Revision & Re-submission Authors Authors address comments point-by-point. Revised manuscripts may undergo a second review round if required.
VI. Final Acceptance Editor-in-Chief Once quality and ethical standards are met, the paper is formally accepted and moved to production.

Hastagina: Jurnal Kriya dan Industri Kreatif maintains rigorous peer review standards to foster quality research in Craft and Creative Industries.